Oakland Terrace Home Page
Gr.2 Unit 3/Gr. 3 Unit 1
Subtraction with Regrouping
What Does This Look Like In:
K 1 2 3 4 5 A B

The lessons here use the base ten block online manipulative:
http://nlvm.usu.edu/

Subtraction with regrouping is an algorithm that can be difficult for many students. When introducing subtraction problems to students, it is important to realize the level of difficulty of the problem. A problem such as 78 - 15 does not cause problems for most students because there is no need to regroup. Once regrouping begins, the problems tend to arise.

Base ten blocks showing the subtraction problem: 44 - 16
Using the online manipulatives, the blue blocks represent the original amount, and the red blocks represent the amount to be subtracted. When a red block and blue block are placed together, the blocks disappear. It is clear to students that in this case, there are not enough ones in the top number to subtract 6. Therefore, they will need to regroup.
Base ten blocks showing the subtraction problem: 44 - 16
The student moves one of the blue tens to the ones place, and the block separates into ten one blocks, leaving 14 one blocks on top. Now, the student can match up all of the blue ones with red ones. As the students perform the steps with the blocks, the program records the subtraction algorithm on the side.
Base ten blocks showing the subtraction problem: 44 - 16
Once all of the regrouping and subtracting is completed, the program shows the correct answer in numbers as the student has shown the correct answer with the blocks.
Regrouping across zeroes poses many problems for students who do not understand the subtraction algorithm. The student sees that there are not enough ones in the top number, but there are also no tens to regroup.
Base ten blocks illustrating the problem 403 - 165
The student recognizes that to get tens, a hundred must first be regrouped to the tens place. When the student moves the hundred block to the tens place, it splits into 10 ten blocks.
Base ten blocks illustrating the problem 403 - 165
Now, one of the ten blocks can be regrouped as ones, leaving 9 ten blocks and 13 one blocks.
Base ten blocks illustrating the problem 403 - 165
Now that all of the regrouping has been completed, the ones can be subtracted. 13 ones minus 5 ones leaves 8 ones.
Base ten blocks illustrating the problem 403 - 165
The students then use the blocks to subtract the tens and hundreds, leaving a difference of 238.
Base ten blocks illustrating the problem 403 - 165

Students can be taught an alternative strategy to solve this problem. Because zeroes in the top number cause problems and lead to so much regrouping, there are ways to make the digits in the top number friendlier, or easier to work with. Students ask themselves how they can get as many 9s in the top number as possible. If they simply take 4 away from the top number, they are left with 399. If they take 4 from the bottom number, they are left with 161. After they complete the subtraction, they see that the difference is the same whether they use the traditional algorithm or the alternative strategy.

Traditional Algorithm and an Alternate Strategy to Solve 403 - 165

 

Indicators:
6.2.5.1 model two-digit addition and subtraction using manipulatives.
6.2.5.2 add and subtract two- and three-digit numbers using alternative strategies.
6.3.5.2 subtract two- and three-digit numbers with regrouping.

These web pages may contain links to one or more pages that are outside MCPS.
MCPS does not control the content or relevancy of these pages.

MCPS HOME | PARENTS | STUDENTS | STAFF | ABOUT MCPS | SCHOOLS | COMMUNITY | BOE
© 1995-2007 Montgomery County Public Schools. All rights reserved.
Contact | Privacy Policy | Nondiscrimination/ADA | Get Adobe Acrobat Reader | Get RealPlayer | Montgomery County